Margaret Fuller1 360x1000
3paradise
9albion
199
2trap
1jesusandjohnwayne
storyparadox2
Learned Hand 360x1000
Margaret Fuller4 360x1000
Storyparadox1
Stormy Daniels 360x1000
5confidencegames
299
Samuel Johnson 360x1000
Maurice B Foley 360x1000
Spottswood William Robinson 360x1000
2jesusandjohnwayne
7albion
1albion
2transadentilist
Thomas Piketty2 360x1000
6albion
13albion
2theleastofus
Margaret Fuller2 360x1000
LillianFaderman
Margaret Fuller 2 360x1000
lifeinmiddlemarch1
Mark V Holmes 360x1000
1lafayette
2lafayette
Susie King Taylor 360x1000
3albion
1madoff
4albion
Gilgamesh 360x1000
1theleasofus
George M Cohan and Lerarned Hand 360x1000
11albion
11632
2gucci
4confidencegames
storyparadox3
2falsewitness
2defense
Margaret Fuller3 360x1000
2lookingforthegoodwar
1gucci
Thomas Piketty3 360x1000
Mary Ann Evans 360x1000
399
Maria Popova 360x1000
1transcendentalist
Lafayette and Jefferson 360x1000
Edmund Burke 360x1000
Margaret Fuller 360x1000
James Gould Cozzens 360x1000
3defense
AlexRosenberg
1defense
Office of Chief Counsel 360x1000
1empireofpain
Thomas Piketty1 360x1000
1lauber
Brendan Beehan 360x1000
6confidencegames
Anthony McCann2 360x1000
8albion'
2albion
5albion
499
2confidencegames
1trap
7confidencegames
1lookingforthegoodwar
lifeinmiddlemarch2
3theleastofus
Richard Posner 360x1000
Tad Friend 360x1000
Anthony McCann1 360x1000
Betty Friedan 360x1000
Adam Gopnik 360x1000
George F Wil...360x1000
10abion
14albion
Susie King Taylor2 360x1000
12albion
1confidencegames
1falsewitness
1paradide
3confidencegames
2paradise
Ruth Bader Ginsburg 360x1000
Margaret Fuller5 360x1000
Forfeited Deposit Income Ordinary Not Capital Gain

Forfeited Deposit Income Ordinary Not Capital Gain

Why Capital Gain?

Code Section 1234A provides that gain or loss attributable to the cancellation, lapse, expiration or other termination of a right or obligation which is or would be a capital asset in the hands of the taxpayer shall be treated as gain or loss from the sale of a capital asset.  Well, there you have it.  If CRI-Leslie had sold the hotel it would have gotten capital gain treatment on the sale.  Nobody questions that. So it should get capital gains treatment on the forfeited deposit it got to keep if you follow along with Code Section 1234A.

Why Not Capital Gain?

There is this subtle nuance, that can be quite important, but is often ignored.  CRI-Leslie was not just sitting on the hotel, holding it as an investment.  It was operating and they were taking depreciation deductions.  That fact throws it out of the definition of a capital asset which is in Code Section 1221.  Code Section 1221 defines capital asset negatively.  It is pretty much everything except certain things including:

read more

Over and over again courts have said that there is nothing sinister in so arranging one’s affairs as to keep taxes as low as possible. Everybody does so, rich or poor; and all do right, for nobody owes any public duty to pay more than the law demands: taxes are enforced exactions, not voluntary contributions. To demand more in the name of morals is mere cant.