Most Recent Posts
Gettysburg Interlude – Understanding Historiography
We get along by practicing a form of apartheid. The educational system is neo-abolitionist. Popular culture remains Lost Cause to a significant extent. The educational system does not pay very much attention to the actual war. Civil War buffs do not pay very much attention to what happened other than things relating to the actual conduct of the war.
Gettysburg Day 2 – Worst Ground I Ever Seen
Originally published on forbes.com on July 4, 2013. ______________________________________________________________________________ The Valley of Death "Battlefield...
The Most Glorious Fourth
The superstition grew apace that this was a mystic courier come with great news from the war—the poetry of the idea excusing and commending it—and on it spread, from heart to heart, from lip to lip and from street to street, till there was a general impulse to have out the military and welcome the bright waif with a salvo of artillery!
And all that time one sorely tried man, the telegraph operator sworn to official secrecy, had to lock his lips and chain his tongue with a silence that was like to rend them; for he, and he only, of all the speculating multitude, knew the great things this sinking sun had seen that day in the east—Vicksburg fallen, and the Union arms victorious at Gettysburg!
But for the journalistic monopoly that forbade the slightest revealment of eastern news till a day after its publication in the California papers, the glorified flag on Mount Davidson would have been saluted and re-saluted, that memorable evening, as long as there was a charge of powder to thunder with; the city would have been illuminated, and every man that had any respect for himself would have got drunk,—as was the custom of the country on all occasions of public moment. Even at this distant day I cannot think of this needlessly marred supreme opportunity without regret. What a time we might have had!
Gettysburg Day 2 – Heading Into Action
The board game Gettysburg by Avalon Hill was published in 1958 and is ground zero of the historical simulation board game hobby. I could not help but brag about the vintage copy that accompanied me on the trip and one of the GGG told me that they had laid a copy on the table the previous night to plan their day.
Walking In Armistead's Footsteps 150 Years Later – Gettysburg Day 3 – Pickett's Charge
The monuments on Cemetery Ridge call it “Longstreet’s Assault”, but it goes down in history and popular imagination as “Pickett’s Charge”. Longstreet’s Assault is more accurate, since Pickett commanded only one of the three divisions. I thought that shift might have been post-war revisionism, since Longstreet fell out of favor among Lost Cause historians. Fred Wieners, our tour guide on Saturday, told me that it was more a matter of Pickett being popular with the Richmond press. He also told us that the idea of a frontal assault on the center after a heavy artillery barrage was probably inspired by the Battle of Solferino in 1859. It worked then. The consequence of the Battle of Solferino was the independence of Italy.
Did Doris Kearns Goodwin Blow It At Gettysburg ?
I think one of the things that we as individual Americans need to always remember is that if something really bad happens in our community, the outpouring of generous support and, if required acts of heroism, will be, in some arbitrarily large percentage, from people with whom we profoundly disagree on deeply held moral beliefs.
Did Doris Kearns Goodwin Blow It At Gettysburg?
This was originally published on forbes.com on July 3, 2013. This reissue is scheduled to post one year from the date of the opening ceremonies for the Gettysburg...
Gettysburg Day 2 – The Advantage of Moving Down The Hill
July 2, 2013 Around 4:30 PM on July 2, 2013, my covivant and I were approaching what thought might be the high point of our Gettysburg experience, well my experience...
Gettysburg Day 2 – Worst Ground I Ever Seen
We had a rather free-ranging conversation over many topics including my trip to Dublin where I noted that none of the public contact people were Irish. Mr. Mullally told me that during the Celtic Tiger period, they had to recruit planners from South Africa. There was an interesting interlude in which CV was quizzing Mr. Mullally about the Irish immigrant experience in America. That was kind of odd since that is my heritage, not his.
The Irish Brigade had a really bad day in the Wheatfield which changed hands several times. Mr. Mullally and I hunted out some regimental markers, which General Buford had told me to be on the look-out for.
CV and I ate the rations we had carried as we were in line for the shuttle bus for our trip to Little Round Top. CV thought we had done enough walking by then. Little Round Top is my next post.
Gettysburg Day 1- Through The Streets To Cemetery Hill
Maybe it is just me, but it seems like if you see someone wearing a T-shirt commemorating a particular unit, it is more than likely an Irish unit. I’ve taken to greeting people wearing them with “Clear the Way” which is a translation of what the Irish Brigade was chanting as they went into battle at Antietam. A fellow, wearing an odd-looking kepi, that I tried it on turned out to be Father Stephen Duncan. Father Duncan told me that he had been reenacting Father William Corby. Father Corby had famously given absolution to the men of the Brigade before they went into action in the Wheatfield on July 2.