Spottswood William Robinson 360x1000
2confidencegames
499
3defense
14albion
George F Wil...360x1000
lifeinmiddlemarch1
Betty Friedan 360x1000
9albion
storyparadox3
Mary Ann Evans 360x1000
Margaret Fuller5 360x1000
2paradise
7confidencegames
3theleastofus
Susie King Taylor2 360x1000
3albion
2defense
5confidencegames
Samuel Johnson 360x1000
1lauber
Ruth Bader Ginsburg 360x1000
1defense
Margaret Fuller3 360x1000
1transcendentalist
2gucci
Mark V Holmes 360x1000
11632
7albion
399
2albion
1empireofpain
Lafayette and Jefferson 360x1000
1madoff
James Gould Cozzens 360x1000
2lafayette
2transadentilist
Adam Gopnik 360x1000
199
lifeinmiddlemarch2
4confidencegames
1falsewitness
2falsewitness
Thomas Piketty1 360x1000
Gilgamesh 360x1000
Edmund Burke 360x1000
5albion
Susie King Taylor 360x1000
10abion
Anthony McCann1 360x1000
8albion'
Anthony McCann2 360x1000
Margaret Fuller 2 360x1000
storyparadox2
Stormy Daniels 360x1000
6confidencegames
1confidencegames
299
6albion
Thomas Piketty2 360x1000
Margaret Fuller2 360x1000
2theleastofus
3paradise
Maria Popova 360x1000
AlexRosenberg
3confidencegames
2jesusandjohnwayne
1trap
Storyparadox1
12albion
Richard Posner 360x1000
Learned Hand 360x1000
George M Cohan and Lerarned Hand 360x1000
1lookingforthegoodwar
1lafayette
1theleasofus
2lookingforthegoodwar
4albion
Office of Chief Counsel 360x1000
LillianFaderman
Margaret Fuller4 360x1000
11albion
Margaret Fuller1 360x1000
Maurice B Foley 360x1000
Thomas Piketty3 360x1000
13albion
1paradide
1albion
Tad Friend 360x1000
Brendan Beehan 360x1000
1gucci
2trap
1jesusandjohnwayne
Margaret Fuller 360x1000

Reilly’s Fourth Law of Tax Planning – Execution isn’t everything, but it’s a lot– stands out as the lesson in a Court of Claims ruling in the case of Andrew C. Dixon.

Background

Mr. Dixon is an Australian bloke living in the United States. The story on his refund claims is a little convoluted. He is seeking to recover $137,656 that he sent in with his 2013 Form 1040 and $189,329.96 that he paid after the 2013 return was audited and $1,588,653 with respect to his 2014 Form 1040. There is an audit of the 2014 return that, according to the ruling, appears to be unresolved.

The amended returns were prepared by John Anthony Castro. As the claim explains, the argument is that gains within Dixon’s Australian Superannuation Fund (the down under version of privatized social security) is exempt from US Taxation (Mr. Dixon here on an E-2 visa was taxed as a US resident).

Here is an explanation of the argument from Castro & Co. website. There is a youtube version which I have not yet been able to review.

For whatever it is worth, the original return was prepared by the Sydney office of PWC.

No Jurisdiction

As it happens, the Court of Claims will not be considering the merits of the argument. Judge Hertling ruled that the Court of Claims lacks jurisdiction because Mr. Dixon did not himself sign the amended returns.

The returns were signed by Attorney Castro. There was a Form 2848 floating around but it had not been signed by Dixon, just by Castro and it did not have the box checked to authorize Castro to sign returns and it was not attached to the returns. Other than that Mrs. Lincoln, how did you enjoy the play?

Appeal Coming

I spoke with Kathryn Nicole Magan who is affiliated with Castro & Co. and represented Mr. Dixon. She told me that there will be an appeal and had no further comment. I reached out to Mr. Castro himself and he wrote to me:

“The U.S. Supreme held that waiver cannot exist where there has been a violation of explicit statutory requirements mandated by Congress since Treasury only has “dispensing power” of its own regulatory requirements. In other words, the Secretary, by and through his agents at the IRS, can only waive their own regulations; not mandates by Congress. We agree, of course. 

In this case, the lower court’s ruling can be read two ways: either that the statute implies a mandate of the taxpayer’s personal signature or that the statute’s reference to regulations extends waiver-immunity to said regulation. 

If the former (requiring the taxpayer’s personal signature), then the lower court read into the statute that which is not there against a plain reading of the statute. Congress mandated “a signature” with details thereupon delegated to Treasury; not “the signature” of the taxpayer. In fact, the lower court’s own opinion in Section II(B)(2), used six paragraphs to explain the taxpayer’s noncompliance with regulations but then, in the next section, held waiver inapplicable based on noncompliance with the statute in order to justify quoting the Supreme Court’s comment that waiver does not apply where there are violations of explicit statutory requirements. According to the lower court, “explicit statutory requirements” includes regulations explicitly referenced in the statute, which is clearly reversible. 

If the latter (that a statute’s reference to regulations extends waiver-immunity to said regulations), that broad of a reading is beyond the pale. An explicit statutory reference to regulations does not elevate those regulations to the status of “explicit statutory requirements” beyond the risk of waiver. To do so renders the very concept of waiver obsolete since all regulations were referenced in some manner by statute. Based on that interpretation, the doctrine of waiver is, for all practical purposes, effectively over. No appellate court would allow that interpretation go unanswered. 

The requirement that a power of attorney accompany an amended return signed under penalties of perjury by an agent was created not by “explicit statutory requirements” enacted by Congress; but by the Secretary’s regulations. Those regulations are subject to waiver by investigating the merits of the claim. According to Revenue Agent Pukhalenko’s own affidavit, he fully investigated the merits of the claim. Therefore, the Secretary, by and though his agents, committed waiver. 

We will be appealing to the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit.”

I have not dug deeply into the Australian Superannuation Fund argument. Superficially, much of the material on it seems to originate with Mr. Castro. I am inclined to hope that the appeal on the signature issue is successful. Nonetheless, win or lose, not having Mr. Dixon sign was an unfortunate short-cut to take.

A Candidate

Not related to the decision in any way, but still of interest, Mr. Castro is running for the Republican nomination to be the US Senator from Texas. According to this story in the Fort-Worth Star Telegram, it does not look like he is likely to get an endorsement from the President, who actually came out for the incumbent quite a while ago.

“If it was proven that President Trump intentionally withheld international aid to compel a foreign government to criminally investigate a political rival, then logic would dictate that one must vote to convict.”

Some of his other positions seem to be a bit unorthodox for a Republican.